In partnership with

Hey {{first_name}},

It's 97 degrees outside, the World Cup is dominating every TV in America, and somewhere out there a buyer is telling themselves the exact same thing they told themselves last July: they're just going to wait for the market to cool off. Bold strategy, given the market has now outlasted three World Cups and at least two "generational" heat waves without ever actually breaking.

Every few months a client tells me they're going to wait for the market to "come back down." I get it — after the last few years, it's a reasonable-sounding plan. It also happens to be almost the opposite of what the data says.

I went back and pulled median home prices from 1950 to today. Seventy-six years. Two recessions serious enough to actually crash prices.

Here's the shape of it.

The pattern, in short:

  • Nominal home prices rose in nearly every single year since 1950

  • The only two real declines: a shallow dip around 1990–91, and the 2006–2011 crash

  • Both were triggered by forced, distressed selling — not by prices simply being "too high"

  • The last comparable rate environment to today (the early 1980s, when rates hit 18%) never produced a price crash at all — just a frozen, slow market

That last point is the one worth sitting with

The 1980s are the better comparison, not 2008

2008 is the crash everyone remembers, so it's the one everyone's braced for. But 2008 had a specific ingredient: millions of homeowners who were underwater, over-leveraged, and eventually foreclosed on — which forced huge volumes of distressed inventory onto the market at any price. That's what actually moves a median down. Not high prices. Forced selling.

The early 1980s looked more like today, structurally. Rates spiked to roughly 18%. Buyer demand froze. Transactions collapsed. And prices kept climbing anyway, because sellers without a foreclosure notice just... didn't sell. The "reset" showed up as a dead market, not a falling one.

That's largely where we are now. Today's homeowners are mostly rate-locked and equity-rich, not underwater. Sellers are increasingly pulling listings and waiting rather than cutting price. Different plumbing than 2008, same plumbing as 1981.

Countering the four reasons I hear most

"I'll just wait for prices to crash."
Prices falling nationally has happened twice in 76 years, and both times required a credit crisis forcing mass distressed sales. There's no equivalent stress in the system right now — delinquencies and foreclosures are low, and most owners have 30-year fixed rates under 6%. Waiting for a crash is waiting for a specific mechanical event, not a vibe.

"I'll wait until rates come back down, then buy."
So will everyone else who's currently on the sidelines for the same reason. Rate drops tend to pull buyer demand forward faster than they pull seller inventory forward, which is exactly the setup that pushes prices up, not down. You're not waiting for a better price — you're waiting for a moment with more competition.

"Home prices have gotten insane — this can't be sustainable."
It's a fair instinct, but the "insane" part is mostly a monthly-payment story, not a price story. Adjusted for inflation, U.S. home values roughly quadrupled between 1940 and 2000 — real, but nowhere near what the sticker prices suggest. Most of the affordability squeeze is rates and stagnant wage growth stacked on top of fairly ordinary long-run appreciation, not runaway real prices.

"I'll wait until things feel normal again."
"Normal" by the 1950–2020 baseline is a market where prices go up most years, buyers who wait pay more, and the exceptions are rare enough to be historical events with names attached to them (the S&L crisis, the subprime crash). Waiting for calm usually just means waiting through more years of appreciation.

What this means locally

Lake County doesn't behave exactly like the national median, but the underlying mechanism is the same: our sellers right now are mostly not distressed, and there's no local wave of foreclosures waiting to hit the market. If anything, tight inventory here means the "wait it out" math is worse locally than nationally — less competition among sellers to bring prices down, even in a slower-transaction environment.

If you're sitting on the sidelines waiting for a number that historically shows up about once every 35–40 years, I'm happy to run the actual numbers for your specific situation — what waiting is likely to cost you in this market versus what it saved people in the two markets where it worked.

A note on the numbers: pre-2000 figures come from Census decennial home values (all owner-occupied homes); 2000-on figures are NAR median existing-home sale prices. Different series, spliced for the long view — the shape holds either way.

A Word From Our Sponsor

Trade Real-World Events. Get $10 Free.

Start trading real-world events. With Kalshi, you can trade on things you already follow: inflation, elections, sports, and more. It’s simple: buy “Yes” or “No” shares on what you think will happen, and earn returns if you’re right.

To get you started, we’re giving you a free $10. Use it to explore the platform, test your instincts, and see how prediction markets work in real time.

Join thousands already trading the news and putting their knowledge to work.

Claim your $10 and start trading now.

Trade responsibly.

The Big Picture

The market doesn't wait for perfect conditions. Neither do the people who end up happy with their decision two years from now. The difference between the ones who moved and the ones who didn't is rarely money or timing — it's usually just the willingness to have one honest conversation about what's actually possible. If you've been sitting on this, that conversation is a good place to start. I'm easy to reach — just hit reply.

Thank you for being here — I don't take it lightly that you let this newsletter into your inbox every week. If this issue was helpful, pass it along to someone who might be thinking about making a move. The forward button is one of the kindest things you can do for someone who doesn't know where to start.

And if you're not already following along on Instagram, come find me — I share market updates, local content, and the occasional thing that didn't make it into the newsletter. @michaelsteber_realtor

Until next week…

If you've enjoyed our service (or the newsletter) please leave a review HERE

Keep Reading